Both York and Edinburgh are fantastic choices for a short stay, and each offers a unique experience. Here’s a comparison to help you decide which might be best suited to your interests and preferences.

York

York is a smaller city with a medieval atmosphere. It’s perfect for a more relaxed visit and you can easily explore most of the city on foot in a few days, York has a quieter, more laid-back pace, making it a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of larger cities. It’s ideal for history and culture lovers and the small size means you can cover most of it without feeling rushed. Below are some of the main attractions we at Stayful think are worth visiting when in the city of York.

York Minster

One of the largest and most beautiful Gothic cathedrals in Northern Europe, if you are visiting York for s short or long stay, this is a must see place.

The Shambles

A picturesque, narrow, and winding street filled with timber-framed buildings, often said to be one of the most photogenic streets  in the UK.

National Railway

Museum Great for train enthusiasts and history buffs.

Other worthy mentions

• York Castle Museum & Clifford’s Tower Offering insights into York’s medieval past.
• City Walls You can walk along York’s ancient city walls for great views of the city.

Edinburgh

A vibrant, cultural, and grand city with a stunning combination of history, architecture, and natural beauty. Edinburgh offers more variety and is slightly larger than York, with a distinct atmosphere, Edinburgh also has a more cosmopolitan feel vs York with a wide variety of activities, from arts and culture to shopping and dining. It’s lively, especially in the summer when festivals fill the streets, below is a list of some of the main attractions or places to visit when enjoying a stay in Edinburgh.

Edinburgh Castle

A dramatic fortress atop a volcanic rock, offering spectacular views of the city and rich history a must when visiting the city for a long or short stay.

Royal Mile

A historic street that runs from the castle to the Palace of Holyroodhouse, lined with shops, attractions, and hidden alleys (called “closes”).

Arthur’s Seat

An extinct volcano offering breathtaking panoramic views of the city, great for a hike.

National Museum of Scotland

A free museum with fascinating exhibits covering everything from Scottish history to science and culture.

Palace of Holyroodhouse

The official residence of the British monarch in Scotland.

Edinburgh’s Old and New Towns

Both are UNESCO World Heritage Sites, with beautiful Georgian architecture, narrow alleyways, and lovely squares.

York vs Edinburgh for a short stay breakdown

Size

York is much smaller, which makes it easier to explore in a shorter time. Edinburgh, though larger, is still very walkable and offers more variety in terms of things to do and see.

Pace of Visit

York offers a more relaxed, slower pace, while Edinburgh offers a faster pace with more to do.

History vs. Culture

If you’re drawn to medieval history and charming streets, York may be a better choice. If you prefer a blend of history, arts, and stunning views, Edinburgh has more to offer.

Accessibility

Edinburgh is a larger city and has an international airport with many more transport connections. York is also accessible by train but may take a little longer to reach, especially from southern parts of the UK.

Conclusion

Go to York if you want a relaxing, picturesque city steeped in medieval history and charm.
if you prefer a bustling, vibrant city with stunning architecture, festivals, and more diverse attractions, then Edinburgh is going to be a better bet

Based on our experience at Stayful, both cities are unforgettable, so it depends on whether you’re seeking a more tranquil retreat or a dynamic city experience!