Sheffield has a fantastic pub scene, with a mix of traditional and contemporary venues. Whether you’re after a cozy, historic pub or a trendy craft beer bar, there’s something for everyone. Here are five of the best pubs the team at Stayful have put together to check out when visiting Sheffield, these pubs offer a wide range of atmospheres, from historic and traditional to trendy and modern, and all are fantastic for soaking up the essence of Sheffield’s vibrant pub scene, so let’s jump right in!

The Sheffield Tap

Located in the iconic Sheffield Train Station, The Sheffield Tap is a must-visit for beer lovers. It’s a classic pub with a modern twist, offering a great range of local ales, craft beers, and continental options. The grand Victorian-style interior adds to the charm, and it’s a fantastic place to grab a drink before heading out to explore the city.

The Fat Cat

Known for its exceptional range of locally brewed beers, The Fat Cat is a haven for craft beer enthusiasts. Situated in the Kelham Island area, which is rapidly becoming a hotbed of great pubs, The Fat Cat is a traditional pub with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. They also serve delicious pub food, and their outdoor seating is perfect for a sunny day.

The University Arms

A classic in the city, The University Arms is perfect for those wanting to experience a traditional British pub with a student vibe. Located near the University of Sheffield, it has a great selection of cask ales, craft beers, and spirits, as well as hearty pub food. It’s a lively spot but with a relaxed and friendly atmosphere.

The Rutland Arms

For something a bit different, The Rutland Arms in the Kelham Island area offers a great combination of locally brewed ales and a stylish, contemporary setting. It’s known for its laid-back atmosphere, excellent food, and friendly service. The pub often hosts events and live music, adding to its vibrant energy.

The Crown and Anchor

If you’re after a classic, no-frills experience, The Crown and Anchor is a great spot. It’s one of Sheffield’s oldest pubs, dating back to the 1800s. This traditional pub serves up cask ales and has a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. It’s a perfect place for enjoying a quiet pint or chatting with locals.

Honorable Mentions

The Library Pub: Quirky and relaxed, a great place for a pint in a cosy setting.
The Hillsborough Hotel: A traditional pub with a great selection of cask ales, popular with locals.